Multi-material 3D printing

Multi-material 3D printing is a 3D printing that consists of two or more components that are connected permanently or movably during printing. The best known is the two color printing with an FDM Idex printer. However, it is not only possible to combine two different colors from the same material. In this article I want to show the possibilities and problems.

Please also note the shrinkage issue.

 

Environmental Protection

Since multi-material components made of different types of plastic often cannot be separated again, recycling is not possible. A multi-material component made of different types of plastic should therefore only be created if there is no other solution. Recycling two identical types of plastic with different colors is not a problem.
 
 

Material combinations 

Suitable material combinations enable interesting technical solutions. Typical examples for the combination of two plastics A and B are: 

Material A Material B
Base color Contrast color
Opark Transparent
Hard / Stiff Soft / Elastic
Standard material ESD material
Standard material Wear-resistant material

Combinations with each other are also possible.

 

Requirements for combining different materials

Two different materials can be combined into one component in different ways. Two types of plastic can be fused together on the surface if they are compatible with each other. The compatibility is the better the more similar the materials are in the polymer composition. Materials that have a very different melting point can therefore not be connected to each other. However, two materials can also be connected to one another via a form fit. In the case of incompatible materials that do not enter into a material connection, you can also create flexible connections in this way.

The safest connection is a material and form-fitting connection. For example, if the connection is to be watertight, it usually has to be firmly bonded so that no gap can arise.
 
 

Material / Filament compatibility

Depending on the material combination, a material bond can be created more or less well. In order to create a compatibility list, we started a new project in which we test the different combinations. The full compatibility list is only available to X40 community members or can be obtained through a donation to the project.
 
Adhesion Test setup
In order to analyze the connection between two different materials, two throws with an edge length of 10mm are printed on top of each other. The components are then pulled apart and evaluated to analyze the layer adhesion between the plastics.
 
Tested filaments
  • Standard PLA = Material4Print PLA
  • Tough PLA = Fiberlogy Impact PLA
  • PETG = 3DJAKE PETG
  • PCTG = Fiberlogy PCTG
  • FiberSilk = Fiberlogy FiberSilk
  • ASA = Fiberlogy ASA
  • GreenTec Pro = Extrudr GreenTec Pro
  • NonOilen = Fillamentum NonOilen
  • DuraBio = Verbatim DuraBio
  • PVB = Prusament PVB
  • HIPS = Fiberlogy HIPS
  • TPU = Polymaker PolyFlex TPU95A
  • PP = Fiberlogy PP
  • OBC Polyethylene = Addnorth OBC Polyethylene
  • I150-PF = Igus I150-PF
  • PMMA = Material4Print PMMA
  • PHA = ColorFabb ALLPHA

 

 
 
 
 
Material A /
Material B
Standard PLA Tough PLA PETG PCTG FiberSilk FiberSatin ASA GreenTEC Pro NonOilen DuraBio PVB HIPS TPU PP OBC Polyethylene PMMA I150-PF PHA
Standard PLA  3 X 1 1  2  X 1 X  3 1  ? 0 2 X 0 1  1  ?
Tough PLA  3  3  1 X X  2 X 3 3 1  ?  X  2 1 0 1  1  ?
PETG  X  1 X 1  2  X 3 X 0 3  ?  X  X  1 0 1  X  ?
PCTG  1  1  1 3  1  1 1 1 0 1  ?  1  2  X X 0  3  ?
FiberSilk  2  X  2 1 X  2 1  X X 1  ?  X  X  0 0 0  1  ?
FiberSatin  X  2  1  X  2  X X  3 3 3  ?  1  X  1 X X  1  ?
ASA 1  X  3  1  1  3 3  3 1  2  ?  1  0  1 0 3  3  ?
GreenTEC Pro 3 3  2  X  3  X  X  X 3  3  ?  1  2  X 0 3  X  ?
NonOilen 3  3  0  0  X  3  1  3 X  0  ?  1  X  0 0 0  0  ?
DuraBio  X  X  3  1  1  X  2  3 0  3  ?  0  1  X 0 2  3  ?
PVB  X  ? ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  3  ? ? ?  ? ?  ?  ?
HIPS  0  3  1  1  1  1  X  1 1  0  ?  3  0  1 0 X  0  ?
TPU  2  2  X  2  3  3  0  X 1  1  ?  X  X  1 0 2  X  ?
PP  3  1  1  1  0  1  1  1 X  0  ?  1  1  3 3 0  0  ?
OBC Polyethylene  0  X  0  X  0  0  0  0 0  0  ?  0  0  3 3 X  1  ?
PMMA  X 1  1  0 0  3 3 3 X  2  ?  3  2  0 0 X  X  ?
I150-PF  1  1  3  X 1  1  3 0 0  3  ?  0  1  0  1  2  2  ?
PHA  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ? ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  X
 
 
Legend:
0 = No adhesion. Test cubes cannot be printed on top of one another due to the lack of layer adhesion 
1 = Very little adhesion. The test cubes can be separated non-destructively with very little force 
2 = Medium adhesion. The test cubes can be separated from each other with force. The components can be destroyed. 
3 = Very good adhesion. The test cubes are fused together and can only be separated with great force. Most of the time, the parts are destroyed. 
X = For test results, see X40-Community cloud. External parties can receive the full document through a donation to the project.
? = Not tested
Joomla templates by a4joomla